The 'Wednesday' Cast Just Confirmed A "Top Secret" Season 2 Fan Theory (2024)

Though viewers are already familiar with the character, Netflix’s Wednesday adds a whole new dimension to the iconic Addams Family daughter. The series — described as a “sleuthing, supernaturally infused mystery” — charts Wednesday Addams’ (Jenna Ortega) years as a student at Nevermore Academy. There, she “attempts to master her emerging psychic ability, thwart a monstrous killing spree that has terrorized the local town, and solve the supernatural mystery that embroiled her parents 25 years ago — all while navigating her new and very tangled relationships.”

Netflix didn’t immediately renew Wednesday for a second season, but co-creators Alfred Gough and Miles Millar were already prepared to continue the story. “Miles and I are talking amongst ourselves about it,” Gough added in a separate Empire interview, per Screen Rant. “There's definitely more that you can explore in the world of the Addamses.”

Fortunately, on Jan. 6, Netflix confirmed that Wednesday Season 2 is, indeed, on the way — with a teaser featuring a voiceover from Ortega as Wednesday and Lady Gaga’s “Bloody Mary,” which has been used in the Wednesday Addams TikTok dance trend. “Over the past few weeks, I’ve been hunted, haunted, and mimicked millions of times across the internet,” Wednesday says in the clip. “It’s been pure torture. Thank you.”

One promising early sign of the show’s Season 1 record-setting viewership was that it didn’t take much convincing to get director Tim Burton on board, from the beginning. “When I read this [script], it just spoke to me about how I felt in school and how you feel about your parents, how you feel as a person,” he explained to Empire in September 2022. “It gave the Addams Family a different kind of reality. It was an interesting combination.”

The Wednesday Season 2 Cast

In addition to Ortega, the Wednesday Season 1 cast included: Christina Ricci (Marilyn Thornhill), Gwendoline Christie (Principal Larissa Weems), Emma Myers (Enid Sinclair), Percy Hynes White (Xavier Thorpe), Hunter Doohan (Tyler Galpin), Joy Sunday (Bianca Barclay), Jamie McShane (Sheriff Galpin), Naomi J Ogawa (Yoko Tanaka), Moosa Mostafa (Eugene Ottinger), Georgie Farmer (Ajax Petropolus), and Riki Lindhome (Dr. Valerie Kinbott). Wednesday’s family is played by Victor Dorobantu (Thing), Catherine Zeta-Jones (Morticia Addams), Luis Guzmán (Gomez Addams), Fred Armisen (Uncle Fester), and Isaac Ordonez (Pugsley Addams).

Following the renewal news, Ortega revealed that she wants Lady Gaga to guest star on Wednesday Season 2. “If Lady Gaga were to be a part, [she and Wednesday] would have to be two monsters that understand each other,” she told Variety on the 2023 Golden Globes red carpet. “I’m sure Netflix would love that.”

Though a potential Gaga cameo remains up in the air, fans can look forward to meeting a new Addams family member in the second season. Though the cast confirmed the news in a video for Netflix's Tudum fan event in Sao Paulo, Brazil, on June 17, Doohan added, “But we don’t know who it is!” However, Ortega hinted that she would “love to see Cousin Itt” drop by.

Prior to the actor signing on to play Wednesday, Millar said he agreed with Gough and director Tim Burton that there would be “no show” if they didn’t find the right actor to fill the titular role. “The search for Wednesday was our primary focus for months and we saw hundreds of actresses. Even though Jenna was on our radar almost immediately, we really wanted to do a deep dive,” he recently explained to GoldDerby. After a “magic” Zoom audition, they immediately called Burton and told him they’d found their star. “She just possessed the role,” Millar added. “She was not only visually perfect, but she had the right attitude, the right intelligence.”

The Wednesday Season 2 Plot

In Tudum’s June 2023 Wednesday cast video, Myers revealed that the second season is “being worked on right now and the storyline is so top secret even we don't know what’s going to happen.” However, Ortega offered some light Season 2 spoilers during a conversation with Elle Fanning for Variety’s Actors on Actors series. “It’s still coming together, but we’ve decided we want to lean into the horror aspect of the show a little bit more,” Ortega, who’s also taking on a producer role, teased in the June feature. “We’re ditching any romantic love interest for Wednesday, which is really great.”

As viewers saw in the inaugural season’s finale, the Hyde is very much still in the picture, and there also might be a stalker at Nevermore, based on the creepy texts and photos Wednesday received from an unknown number. “[The stalker proves] that threats remain out there… to both Wednesday and the school,” Millar explained to Tudum. “Not all not loose ends have been tied up neatly as she thinks they have.”

The Wednesday Season 2 Fan Theories

At Tudum, the Wednesday cast also reacted to several Wednesday Season 2 fan theories, including that Eugene might have picked up the slain Crackstone’s ring and could even inherit the villain’s powers. “I do think he would want to claim some sort of vengeance on anybody who’s ever bullied him,” Ortega said.

As for the idea that Wednesday might be the new Hyde Master and have some sort of control over Tyler now, she joked, “I’ve always thought it would be really, really interesting if Wednesday had a monster as a pet.” Doohan, for his part, chimed in that he’d “bow down to Jenna,” though admitting, “Wednesday would probably come up with something horrible for me to do.”

Doohan also weighed in that a theory that Weems is alive and took on the form of Lurch in the Season 1 finale “makes sense,” evidenced by a seemingly changed eye color.

The Wednesday Season 2 Premiere Date

Wednesday’s first outing reportedly began production in September 2021 and wrapped filming in Bucharest, Romania, in March 2022 — add in post-production, and it seems that a premiere anytime before 2024 would be pretty unlikely. At least we know more Wednesday is on the way, though — even if it takes a while.

This post will be updated as more Wednesday Season 2 details become available.

This article was originally published on

The 'Wednesday' Cast Just Confirmed A "Top Secret" Season 2 Fan Theory (2024)

FAQs

The 'Wednesday' Cast Just Confirmed A "Top Secret" Season 2 Fan Theory? ›

However, the one fan theory the cast confirmed is actually going to happen is the speculation that another Addams Family member will arrive during Season Two. “This is true,” the castmates all confirm.

Who is the new cast member of Wednesday Season 2? ›

Wednesday's world is expanding in Season 2 with a slew of new series regulars, including: Steve Buscemi (The Big Lebowski, Boardwalk Empire), Billie Piper (Scoop, I Hate Suzie), Evie Templeton (Return to Silent Hill, Lord of Misrule), Owen Painter (Tiny Beautiful Things, The Handmaid's Tale), and Noah Taylor (Law & ...

Why is Percy Hynes White not returning to Wednesday? ›

According to The Independent, Netflix dropped Hynes White, one of the main actors in the first series, following allegations of sexual misconduct made against the star last year.

Who won t be in Wednesday season 2? ›

And that includes a specific actor who will not be returning for season 2, despite his big role in season 1. That would be Percy Hynes White's Xavier Thorpe.

Who played the hide in Wednesday? ›

She eventually discovers that the murderer is a Hyde, the monstrous alter ego of Tyler Galpin (Hunter Doohan). Tyler's Hyde identity first appeared when he was a baby and his father kept it a secret for his whole life, in hopes he would never again transform.

Is Xavier coming back to Wednesday season 2? ›

Percy Hynes White, who played Wednesday's love interest Xavier Thorpe in season 1 of the Netflix series Wednesday, isn't coming back to reprise his role because of allegations against him.

What cast member quit Wednesday? ›

For season two of Wednesday, our titular weirdo will have some new faces joining her, but that also means that some people will not be returning, at least not to their full capacity. Deadline confirmed that Percy Hynes White, Jamie McShane and Naomi J Ogawa will not return as series regulars.

Why isn't Yoko in Wednesday season 2? ›

Jamie McShane (Sheriff Donovan Galpin, father of Tyler Galpin) and Naomi J. Ogawa (fellow student Yoko Tanaka) have also departed ahead of season 2. (Ogawa cited uncertain scheduling and a lack of progression in Yoko's journey as the reason for her exit.)

Who has been dropped from Wednesday season 2? ›

After waiting for a while, Jenna Ortega dropped the best announcement that Wednesday, Season 2, started production, and she also revealed the cast along with it. And fans now confirm that Percy Hynes White has been dropped from the show amidst serious allegations reported last year.

What actors are not returning to Wednesday Season 2? ›

Naomi J. Ogawa, who played Nevermore Academy vampire student Yoko Tanaka, is not returning. Lead Percy Hynes White, who played Xavier Thorpe, another Nevermore Academy student with psychic abilities, also won't be back.

Who is Wednesday's boyfriend? ›

Within her first week at Nevermore Academy, Wednesday reunites with Xavier Thorpe, who she actually knew from childhood. He's the ex-boyfriend of Nevermore's Queen Bee, Bianca Barclay, but becomes intrigued by Wednesday's presence at the school.

Does Wednesday love Tyler? ›

Wednesday's Tyler is Likable But a Monstrous Mess

In time, though, she does realize she's self-centered and might not be best-suited for the young barista. Still, they go to the school dance, have a date and share a kiss, with Wednesday liking the light in him and how he brings out the best in her.

Was Tyler's mom a hyde? ›

In Xavier's art studio, Tyler finds himself chained to a chair. Wednesday then reveals to him that his mother was a hyde as well as a former student of Nevermore. After Wednesday stated that she's going to torture Tyler, the nightshades left.

Who is the new Wednesday girl? ›

Jenna Ortega's new Wednesday co-star Thandiwe Newton just joined Tim Burton's acting family, following in the footsteps of an actor she's very familiar with. Variety reported Tuesday that Newton would be joining Season 2 of the hit Netflix Netflix 0.0% series in an unspecified role.

Did they change actors in Wednesday? ›

Joining Ortega in season two of Wednesday will be Catherine Zeta-Jones and Luis Guzman, who play Morticia and Gomez Addams. New cast members include Scoop actor Billie Piper, Evie Templeton, Owen Painter and Noah Taylor.

Who is the new principal in Wednesday season 2? ›

Steve Buscemi has joined the cast of “Wednesday” Season 2 at Netflix, Variety has learned exclusively from sources. Exact character details are being kept under wraps, but sources say Buscemi will play the new principal of Nevermore Academy.

Is Tyler going to be in Wednesday Season 2? ›

Yes, the cast members who survived season one—Hunter Doohan (Tyler Galpin), Emma Myers (Enid Sinclair), Joy Sunday (Bianca Barclay), Catherine Zeta-Jones (Morticia Addams), Luis Guzmán (Gomez Addams), and Fred Armisen (Uncle Fester), alongside Ortega's Wednesday Addams—will all be returning.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kerri Lueilwitz

Last Updated:

Views: 5933

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (67 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kerri Lueilwitz

Birthday: 1992-10-31

Address: Suite 878 3699 Chantelle Roads, Colebury, NC 68599

Phone: +6111989609516

Job: Chief Farming Manager

Hobby: Mycology, Stone skipping, Dowsing, Whittling, Taxidermy, Sand art, Roller skating

Introduction: My name is Kerri Lueilwitz, I am a courageous, gentle, quaint, thankful, outstanding, brave, vast person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.